How can we improve Alma?

Need a way to retrieve HOLDINGS where there are no ITEMS associated with the holding

Currently, there is no good way in either Advanced Repository search or Analytics to retrieve Holdings records that do not have items attached. The "has no inventory" indexing only returns bibs with no holdings, not holdings with no items. In order to have the holdings fields exposed to the Repository Search, you must select either Physical Title or Physical Item, which then only looks at records where there is an associated item record.

The same seems to be true in analytics. I can create an analysis using the Titles table and filter to "Number of Physical Items (All) = 0", but the Titles table does not index any holdings information (i.e. is it a microform or print?, what are our summary holdings?). If I try to pull the same list using the Physical Items table, I can get a list of titles within a given resource type, but as soon as I try to filter by "Num of Items", the list is reduced to just those titles which have ITEMS. If I try to filter to Num Items=0, or Num Items IS NULL, "No results" is returned, even though I get over 1800 titles returned from the previously described analysis from the Titles table. What I find even more counter-intuitive is that when I remove the Num of Items column and add in Holding Id, the results are limited to the same titles which have physical items. Even though there are holdings, and therefore holdings IDs, for many more titles, they are not included in the results. It seems as though not all holdings records are being indexed for this table, but instead, only those holdings related to items -- even though ALL bibs are indexed. Please index all holdings for both Analytics purposes and repository search.

167 votes
Vote
Sign in
Check!
(thinking…)
Reset
or sign in with
  • facebook
  • google
    Password icon
    Signed in as (Sign out)
    You have left! (?) (thinking…)
    Betsy R. shared this idea  ·   ·  Admin →

    3 comments

    Sign in
    Check!
    (thinking…)
    Reset
    or sign in with
    • facebook
    • google
      Password icon
      Signed in as (Sign out)
      Submitting...
      • AdminAsaf Kline (Director, Product Management, Ex Libris) commented  · 

        Thanks for the great idea, which specifically points out the need to be able to report on holdings with no items in Alma Analytics. Our plans have been updated accordingly and the Physical Item subject area will be enhanced to support these types of queries

      • Betsy R. commented  · 

        Ah-ha! You are correct, "has items" under the holdings column wlll work in Repository "Physical Titles" search. So now I can find them to work on them within Alma. Thank you!

        I leave this suggestion here, though, because the need to REPORT against info in the holdings records is still needed.

      • Anonymous commented  · 

        There is a "has items" criterion for holdings in the advanced search which allow retrieval of holdings that have no items. However, it would still be extremely useful to be able to identify holdings without items in analytics too.

      Feedback and Knowledge Base